New Match on an Old Flame - Cover

New Match on an Old Flame

by EveryDenialShorts

Copyright© 2025 by EveryDenialShorts

Erotica Sex Story: A young girl shows up at the house of the man who raped her a year ago. At first, she just wants to talk, but ends up naked in his living room. But what are her real intentions?

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft   ft   Consensual   Rape   Fiction   Cream Pie   Masturbation   Small Breasts   .

Rain battered the porch in relentless sheets, each gust turning the world past the steps into a shifting curtain of water. She stood under the porch light, hair slicked down and dripping against her cheeks, water running along her jaw and soaking into the collar of her white top. The fabric clung to her skin, turned almost transparent by the downpour, her bra visible beneath, straps against her shoulders. Short denim shorts hugged her hips, the edges dark with rain, beads of water sliding down her bare thighs. She shivered, arms crossed for warmth, or maybe just to hold herself together.

She raised a fist and knocked, the sound barely audible over the constant rush of the storm. The wind picked up and blew a face full of rain against her, but she didn’t flinch. She waited, unmoving, shivering and soaking wet, and then knocked again, three hard raps on the door.

The man who opened the door looked like he hadn’t slept, the blue of his eyes clouded and distant, jaw rough with stubble. His hair stuck up at odd angles, as if he’d been dragging his hands through it all night. The porch light caught the tension in his face, his mouth pulled tight as he stared at her in disbelief.

“You ... You shouldn’t be here.” His voice shook, caught somewhere between fear and guilt. His hand gripped the doorframe, knuckles tense. “Not after what happened.”

She stayed firm in place on the wet, wooden porch. Rainwater was streaming down her legs, eyes fixed on him.

“You raped me,” she said, and the words fell heavy and sharp, cutting through the hiss of the rain.

For a moment, neither of them breathed. The rain hammered the porch roof, water trickling in cold rivulets down her spine. Her words seemed to freeze the air between them, a truth neither could step around.

“You did your time, and that doesn’t erase it.” She hugged herself tighter, her voice steady, even as her body shook. “But I’m not here for vengeance. I just want to talk.”

He swallowed, his Adam’s apple bobbing in his throat. A tremor passed through him, as if the storm might drag the whole house into the dark. He stepped back, uncertain, letting the door swing open wider. The hallway behind him was dim, shadows trailing along the peeling wallpaper, the faint smell of stale coffee and dust filling her nose. A familiar smell.

“Come in,” he finally said, the words barely above a whisper.

She lingered on the threshold, glancing back into the storm. The street was empty, water gushing down the gutters and pooling in the cracks of the sidewalk. A streetlamp flickered across the way, painting the little it could reach in amber light. For a heartbeat, she wondered if she should turn around, let the rain swallow her whole, and pretend she’d never come. Doubt twisted in her stomach, cold and sharp. Was this the right thing to do? She wasn’t sure. Maybe she’d never be sure.

But she didn’t let herself hesitate any longer. With a slow breath, she stepped inside, brushing past him. The warmth of the house pressed against her rain-chilled skin. She slipped her flip flops off, letting them sit by the door. Barefoot now, she glanced down, watching little puddles form around her toes.

“My clothes are soaked,” she said quietly, voice almost apologetic. Droplets slid from her hair, dripping onto her shirt and running down the line of her bra.

He slowly closed the door, checking twice to make sure it stayed unlocked. He shoved his hands deep in the pockets of his sweatpants. He looked at her, he really looked at her. As if seeing her for the first time all over again. She could see the hesitation, the guilt, the confusion flickering across his face. He seemed caught between wanting to help and not knowing how, as if any gesture might cross an invisible line neither of them could define.

“Do you have a dryer?” she asked nervously, as if unsure whether it was okay to need something so ordinary in a moment so fragile. She wrapped her arms around herself again, hugging her waist, goosebumps rising along her arms.

He nodded with a sigh. Relieved for the simple request.

“Yeah. It’s ... just downstairs.” He pointed toward a narrow door off the hallway, its paint chipped and handle dull from years of use. “Through there. The basement.”

“Do you mind if I...?” Her eyes flicking from the door to him.

He shook his head, cutting her off.

“Help yourself.” He shifted, stepping back from the entryway, making it clear he had no intention of following her by walking into the living room.

She nodded, her wet hair trailing droplets behind her as she padded across the cold floor. The old door creaked as she pulled it open, a breath of cool air spilling up from below. She paused on the top step, glancing back at him, but he was already looking away, gaze fixed on some distant place past the front window. Gathering herself, she started down the steps alone, bare feet chilled on the hard surface. The door swung closed behind her with a hollow click, the house settling back into silence as she disappeared into the shadows below.

The basement light flickered as she found the switch. Down here, the world felt even quieter, insulated from the rain, the only sound was the distant rumble of thunder. The concrete floor was cold beneath her bare feet, sending a sharp chill up her spine as she descended the last few steps. For a second she just stood there, breath held tight in her chest, letting her eyes adjust to the dimness.

She paused as she walked towards the edge of a studio setup. A mattress at the center and a camera pointed towards it. Two studio lights were pointed towards the setup, ensuring everything that happened there was lit perfectly.

This was the room. This was the bed.

She remembered the roughness of his hands, the way he’d pushed her down, her body pinned to that very mattress. The lights had burned hot overhead, chasing away every shadow, leaving her nowhere to turn, nowhere to hide. His voice was cold, commanding, and echoed in her ears even now. She remembered the pain, the way her body had fought and then gone numb. The camera’s shutter had clicked, again and again, capturing her while she was exposed, when she’d had no say, no control. She had been broken in, reduced to being just a hole for him to fuck, something to fill and document.

Standing there now, her body remembered everything. Muscles tensed, breath shallow, her skin crawling with the memories. The sheets had been washed, the lights were off, but nothing could erase what happened here. Nothing could make her forget the feel of his weight, his hands, his cock inside her, forcing her to the edge over and over again until her body had betrayed her, her orgasm wrenched from her by sheer exhaustion.

She let out a sigh and forced herself to keep moving, to step past the bed and the camera, to remind herself that this was a different night, that she had come here on her own terms.

She found the washer and dryer tucked neatly beneath the small window, against the back wall. The space was narrow, a shelf above crowded with detergent bottles and a few faded towels. She glanced at the small window above, rain still streaming down the glass in twisting rivulets.

She peeled off her soaked shirt first, the fabric clinging to her skin before giving way and landing with a wet slap in the empty drum. Her fingers worked the button on her shorts, sliding the denim down her hips, the heavy fabric sticking to her thighs before she stepped out of them, dropping them into the dryer beside her shirt. She reached back and unclasped her bra, slipping it off her shoulders, shivering a little as the air touched her bare breasts, nipples hard from the chill. Last, she hooked her thumbs into the waistband of her panties, sliding them down and stepping out of them, adding them to the dryer.

She grabbed a towel from the shelf above, quickly drying off her body. After barely being able to dry her hair, she threw the towel in with the rest of her clothes. She then pulled a dryer sheet from the box, closed the door, and hit the start button.

As the machine began to hum, she started walking back to the stairs. She lingered for a moment at the basement door, listening to the low drone of the dryer and the distant patter of rain on the roof that she could once again hear. The cool air clung to her skin, raising goosebumps along her arms and legs. She hugged herself, drawing in a breath, before slowly easing the door open.

The hallway beyond was quiet and dim, the hush of the storm outside broken only by the soft creak of the old floor beneath her bare feet. She stepped into the light, feeling strangely weightless, each step a reminder of her vulnerability, the reality of being naked and alone in the home of her rapist.

There was a flickering light coming from the living room, the crackle of a fire. She walked toward it, the wood floor smooth beneath her feet. Her pulse quickened as she reached the archway, stepping into the open space. He was standing at the window once more, looking out at the dark and the rain. Her footsteps were silent as she approached him, stopping at the edge of the living room. She watched him for a moment, her voice catching in her throat, before she spoke.

“Hey,” she said quietly, not wanting to startle him.

He turned, his eyes going wide when he saw her, taking in her nudity, the goosebumps rising along her bare legs and arms, her hair still wet, a droplet trailing along her neck and down the curve of her breast. He was speechless, his mind struggling to process what he was seeing, trying to make sense of the reality of her being here, and the fact that she was naked.

“Nothing you haven’t seen before, right?” She gave a weak smile, hugging herself tighter. “Guess there’s not much left for me to hide in this house.”

He swallowed, shame flickering in his eyes, but unable to look away from her body, his shoulders stiff.

“I’ll, uh ... I can get you a towel to cover up?” He offered, voice catching.

“Don’t bother.” She shook her head, her gaze steady. “I think we’re past pretending I need to cover up for your comfort.”

She moved past him, bare feet making almost no sound on the wood as she crossed to the couch by the fire. The warmth hit her skin, coaxing out another shiver, but she didn’t flinch or reach for a blanket. Instead, she settled in, crossing her legs and keeping her arms wrapped around herself, letting him take in her bareness, her vulnerability, the firelight dancing along her skin.

He was silent, but didn’t look away. She could see the conflict, the struggle in his face, torn between staring and trying to avert his eyes. He couldn’t seem to decide where to put his hands, fingers flexing at his sides.

“Will you sit with me?” she asked, patting the spot on the couch beside her.

He hesitated, the words catching in his throat. For a long moment, he just stood there, staring.

“Please?” She kept her voice gentle. “We need to talk.”

He exhaled, breath shaking. He didn’t say a word as he sat down beside her, not close enough to touch, but not so far he couldn’t reach her if he tried. He kept his eyes locked on her, his gaze trailing along her bare thighs, the swell of her breasts, her arms crossed under them, pushing them up just a little.

“I didn’t expect to see you,” he finally said, his voice quiet. “Not ever.”

“I didn’t expect to come back.” She shrugged, her eyes fixed on the flames. “But I did.”

He ran a hand through his hair, letting it trail down the back of his neck. His shoulders tensed, the shadows playing along his face. He stared into the fire for a moment, jaw locking, searching for words he couldn’t quite find. The silence between them felt thick. He glanced at her again, gaze softening just a fraction as the heat of the flames danced over her skin.

“I thought ... after everything, you’d never want to see me again.” His voice was hoarse, almost broken.

She let out a small, brittle laugh.

“At first I didn’t.” She uncrossed her legs, shifting slightly on the cushion, letting her arms fall to her side, leaving her exposed and unguarded. “But I couldn’t keep running from what happened. Or from you.”

He looked at her, confusion flickering in his eyes.

“Then ... why are you here? After everything, after--” He stopped, the words knotting up in his throat, shame and uncertainty warring on his face. “I don’t understand.”

She watched the fire for a moment, then met his gaze, her eyes dark and bright at the same time.

“I’m sorry,” she said quietly, her voice trembling. “For turning you in.”

He blinked, startled.

“You’re sorry?” He shook his head, searching her face for an answer, for something that made sense. “You shouldn’t be. I ... what I did ... I deserved to be turned in. You know that. Hell, I deserved worse than that. I still do. One year in prison was s a fucking joke for what I did to you. To all those girls. And ... and if it weren’t for you, I might have never stopped. So ... why the hell are you apologizing? After everything, why are you saying that? Why are you here? Why did you come back?”

She breathed in slowly, feeling the warmth of the fire on her skin, the weight of his words settling in her chest. For a long moment, she just stared at the flames, as if they might answer for her. When she finally spoke, her voice was barely more than a whisper, but steady.

“Because I never stopped thinking about you,” she said. “Even after everything you did. Even after all the hurt and all the anger and all the reasons I should have hated you and moved on, I couldn’t shake it.” She drew a breath, her fingers curling against the edge of the cushion. “I tried. God, I tried. I told myself it wasn’t worth it, that I was just looking for something to latch onto or some kind of new ending ... but it wasn’t just that.”

He watched her, stunned, unsure whether to be hopeful or afraid.

“I came back because I needed to know if there was anything left. Anything real. Anything underneath all that pain. And because, for reasons I can’t even explain, I care about you. Maybe I always will after the experiences we shared together.” She looked away, her mouth trembling. “I know I’m not supposed to think that, but it’s the truth.”

He let the words settle, his breath shallow, face caught somewhere between disbelief and aching hope. The fire stopped crackling for a moment, and the rain outside had a lull, slowing its downpour, no longer beating against the windows, as if the whole world was holding its breath with them.

“I don’t deserve that,” he finally managed. “I don’t deserve any piece of you, not after what I did. I think about it every day. How I hurt you. How I violated you. I can still see it, feel it. Everything. The way you looked at me. The way you begged me to stop. Those video and pitcures, and the way your body looked. Your face, after I ... the tears, the fear. I did that. And I can never take it back. So, no, you shouldn’t care about me. Because I’m a monster. And you’re ... you’re a beautiful girl. I ... I shouldn’t have said that. But you know what I mean.” He sighed. “I want you to hate me. It would be easier. For both of us.”

She shook her head slowly, her wet hair stuck to her shoulders.

“I know. But hating you didn’t fix anything. I thought it would, but it just ate me up from the inside. I can’t change what happened. I can’t change what you did. But what I can do, is find a way to forgive you. To move forward, somehow. And part of that plan was ending up naked in your house, so here we are. Not sure what that says about me. But it’s a start. A trusting start.”

She let out a breath, the tension slowly easing from her shoulders, leaving her bare and open, the firelight warm and bright against her skin. He watched her, gaze lingering on the softness of her thighs, the curve of her hip, the delicate line of her collarbone. For a moment, the room seemed to melt away, until there was nothing left but her.

She shivered, the air suddenly cool against her naked skin, the chill seeping down her spine.

“I’m cold,” she said, her lips quivering. “Brrr. Can I ... can we sit closer?”

He hesitated, but shifted slightly, his arm stretching out, giving her space to move in.

She slid across the cushion, bare skin brushing his side as she settled into the crook of his shoulder. A breath caught in her chest, heart pounding against her ribs. She felt exposed and fragile, but her nerves began to fade, her body relaxing into the warmth of his presence. His arm was being her back, his hand pressing down on the couch beside her thigh. She reached for his hand, moving it gently onto her leg. He was tentative at first, unsure, but slowly let his palm rest against her skin.

He sat frozen, his fingers trembling just slightly against the smooth warmth of her thigh. The contact was careful, as if he were afraid she might shatter beneath his touch, or he might. They both stared into the fire, the flickering light washing over their faces, softening the edges of all their invisible scars.

For a long moment, neither of them spoke. His thumb began to move lazily, just above her knee, testing the fragile permission she’d given him. She didn’t pull away. If anything, she leaned in a little more, pressing her cheek lightly against his shoulder, letting his heat and the fire’s glow soak into her skin.

“It’s strange,” she said quietly, watching the flames dance. “I should hate this. I should hate you. But right now, I just feel ... safe. I feel safe, for the first time in a long time. I know I shouldn’t, but here, with you, I can’t shake the feeling that you would never hurt me again, or let anyone hurt me again. That I could trust you, even after everything. I don’t know how, but ... I just do. Does that make any sense? Do you know what I mean?”

His hand stayed on her thigh, warm and gentle, careful not to move any higher.

“Just ... let me know if you ever want me to stop touching you, just say so.” He swallowed, his fingers tensing against her.

“I put your hand there, didn’t I? This isn’t exactly what I was expecting when I came back here, but if I’d known how nice this would be, I might have suggested it sooner. Just sitting together like this, by the fire, your hand on my leg. Feels good, doesn’t it?” She shifted, sliding closer, until she was pressed hard against his side, the curve of her hip against his. “This is the closest thing I’ve had to peace since those nights. Even though I’m naked, even though we’re in your living room, even though, a year ago, you raped me. It’s fucked up, and I don’t understand it. But I’m not going to fight it. I’m not going to tell you to stop.”

He breathed in, a tremble passing through his shoulders. His eyes flickered down, drinking in the sight of her bare body, her skin golden in the firelight.

“Do you want me to touch you more?” he asked, voice trembling. “I will. I just need to hear it from you. I need to know this is okay.”

She hesitated, her stomach flipping, a slow shiver rising along her spine. It was a huge step from him, asking her for permission before moving forward, and she knew what she had to do.

“You can do anything you want to me, as long as you ask first.” She reached up and trailed her fingers down the curve of his stubbled jaw before letting her hand rest over his heart, feeling its quickened beat. “I trust you. And that’s the scariest part. But I do.”

He looked at her, blue eyes wide. His breathing slowed, cautious about his next words.

“Can I...” He cleared his throat, his pulse beating wildly under her palm.

“What do you want to do to me?” she asked softly.

“Can I kiss you?” His voice was tight, barely above a whisper.

A sharp tingle ran through her, and her mouth went dry. She swallowed, her chest suddenly tight.

“Okay,” she whispered. “Yes. Kiss me.”

Her fingers tightened against his shirt, her pulse throbbing in her ears. She turned up towards him, letting her lips brush his, the faint scratch of his stubble on her chin, her breath held, caught between the past and the future, waiting.

The touch was slow and soft, his lips brushing hers, a tenderness to the contact that felt almost like an apology. His hand stayed on her thigh, the other coming up, fingertips touching her cheek, his touch so light and careful it might have been a dream. The kiss lingered, a moment held, her pulse fluttering under her ribs.

He broke the kiss first, eyes wet and shining as he pulled back, a tear slipping down his cheek. He pressed his forehead gently to hers, breath shaky, his hand trembling where it rested on her skin.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered, his voice cracking. “God, I’m so sorry. For everything. I don’t know if I’ll ever stop being sorry.”

She looked up at him, her own eyes tearing up, and brushed her thumb over his cheek, catching the tear.

“Stop apologizing,” she said softly. “I forgive you. I do. You don’t have to say it again. Not to me.”

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In